Impression: I saw this film because I remember seeing Ida by the same director, Paweł Pawlikowski, a couple of years ago and liking it. I liked this one even more. Also shot in black and white, it’s like a 1940’s and 1950’s Romeo and Juliet set in Poland (and abroad), but where the forces keeping the lovers apart are themselves and sometimes political realities or social norms of the countries they reside in. The film opens with a scene of a Polish winter and snow that was so bleak and realistic that my husband commented how cold it was in the room. Granted, we soon discovered the window was open, so I guess it’s possible it had nothing to do with the stark realism of the movie. I also loved the early scenes of a group of ethnomusicologists travelling the Polish country side collecting traditional music.
Visually, Pawlikowski’s work is very interesting. Other than the obvious rejection of color, he uses interesting camera angles which especially became obvious towards the end of the film. He frames his characters in the bottom half of the frame and leaves the top of the frame there for you to interpret. Weight of circumstances? God? I don’t know. He is also keen of abrupt endings in both his films, and he loves long black screens between acts. And each act leaves you waiting for more. The transition between the church walls and the mud on the road was striking, and it took me a while to notice there was a mirror in the dance hall scene. On a personal note, it’s also one of very few major movies to feature scene from my very photogenic hometown.
The acting is especially good from both leads. Joanna Kulig feels like a Polish Jennifer Lawrence. Not only because there is a bit of a physical similarity, but because of the acting style, and in that I could very easily have imagined Lawrence playing this role as well. Tomasz Kot feels like a classic leading man from that era of Hollywood films.
In addition to all of this, the backdrop of post World War II era political climate in Poland and France is presented in interesting ways. The film doesn’t fall into the easy trap of most films which portray that era as East=bad West=good. Instead, it shows that even hanging out in smoky bars with libertine Parisians is not all its cracked up to be. The more I think about this film, the more I like it. It’s the best film I’ve seen in a while. I would say, almost a perfect film.
Facts: Black and white rendering of a love story in the late 40s and early 50s in Poland and abroad.
My Buddhist reading: I guess, as most tragic love stories, it’s about our inability to escape samsara, our inability to get what we want, no matter how much we want it. The causes and conditions always conspiring to not allow us to have permanent happiness.